Event details from: From “Unnamed Blanks” To Self-Consciousness — From Critical Intersex Studies to a new Movement History  

Date
7 February 2025
Time
11:00

Following directly from the introductory lecture, this seminar is focused around the intersex movement’s rhetoric: the techniques used to challenge clinical (sexological) authority, in both satirical and theoretical registers. Satire was deployed primarily as a tool to establish intersex self-consciousness: allowing intersex people to come to terms with the (traumatic) ways in which they’d been apprehended by clinical observers. (I call these the terms used to know over them.) Theoretically, intersex writers have attempted to disrupt conventional outlooks on sex (revealing themselves after decades being hidden away, as the underbelly of sex’s fabricated bifurcation), while pulling useful frameworks from existing radical traditions. These registers—political and intellectual, satirical and theoretical, trolling and analytic—have seldom been read together (until now!)

The first part of this seminar will preview and discuss two extracts from Juliana’s forthcoming book Hermaphrodite Logic. The book aims to provide a history of the intersex movement, furthering a fully responsive philosophy of sex (which Juliana argues the movement reveals to be labile and expressive, while those outside its dyadic strictures are left hidden away and thus left needing to reveal or unveil themselves). The two extracts are intended to give glimpses of each of these twin faces (historical and philosophical, political and intellectual). The key point is that intersex people are known over through frameworks applied to them: but have proven able to master a fluency in these clinical ‘terms of art’ more quickly than clinicians can keep track of. (Far from the last word, the outlooks of medics came to serve as a movement punchline.)

The first extract recounts the first public appearance of the Intersex Society of North America (represented by just two members: Max Beck and Morgan Holmes), who together with allies picketed the American Academy of Pediatrician’s annual event, in Boston. The second extract provides an overview of two intersex theorists who provide quite divergent accounts of sex: Christopher Breu and Iain Morland, despite closely shared personal experiences with intersex variations (and the mis/treatments routinely meted out to those born with them). As well as a political challenge to clinical authority, the intersex movement elaborated on fully elaborated theoretical challenges to conventional understandings of sex. This means a fully fledged history of intersex liberation must also be an intellectual history.

The closing hour of the session will open the floor to existing intersex scholarship, discussing specifically David Rubin’s essay on John Money: “An Unnamed Blank that Craved a Name”: A Genealogy of Intersex as Gender. Here Rubin outlines the limitations of “gender” as a means of understanding intersex (as opposed to intersex mis/treatments as the origin of gender—as sexologists faced down the limitations of their efforts to comprehensively “map” sex between two developmental buckets, M/F). Gender is the cart, and intersex the horse.

Throughout, Hermaphrodite Logic is methodologically critical of scholarship which reduces our scope to “critical histories of sexology” (rather than fully integrating the intersex movement which most challenged clinical authority around sex). Concepts are always rewritten by struggle (both for future generations, and retroactively). Nevertheless, the work of Rubin and many other historians of sex(ology) provides a “condition of possibility” for the argument made throughout Hermaphrodite Logic. A critical history of sex is the ladder which a dedicated view of intersex struggle must kick away beneath it, as we climb. Between us, this animating contradiction will be fully teased out as we close.

Juliana Gleeson is a writer. Raised in west London—based in east Berlin—she’s known for exploring lesbianism, comparative religion, leather culture, and communism. Her debut Hermaphrodite Logic is out with Verso Books in June 2025—providing a new history of the intersex movement (just in time for Pride). She was an editor of groundbreaking anthology Transgender Marxism (2021), with Elle O’Rouke. Juliana’s many essays, reviews and dialogues have been published in both high and low presses. Since 2017 she’s performed with queer comedy troupes, hosted salons for subversives, and lectured for pay worldwide.

(No pdfs of readings will be circulated in advance but print outs will be distributed at the lecture on February 6.)

For registration: catrinelradoi@gmail.com
Credits: 1, 2 or 6 ECTS

Organized by the ASCA Research Group Sex Negativity