Event details from: Empire for Rent: Diagnosing Domination on Social Media

Date
30 October 2024
Time
16:00

Social media platforms have proclaimed their services are "free and always will be", while simultaneously enjoying unprecedented financial success. This paper argues this success has come at the expense of users. More precisely, platforms create user dependency, gather extensive behavioural data, and, crucially, manipulate user behaviour to align with the interests of platform customers – advertisers.

This paper presents a normative basis for a fundamental shift in the regulatory approach to social media platforms, which have hitherto concentrated excessively on issues of data collection and privacy or anti-market solutions. Drawing from a republican framework, this paper contends that platforms enable a contemporary form of structural domination. Platforms empower third-parties, including advertisers and political actors, to wield arbitrary interference over users. This power dynamic underlies far-reaching consequences, including escalating hate speech and political polarisation.

By adopting a republican framework, this paper demonstrates how identifiable agents drive platforms to pursue objectives that allow for user manipulation and shifts the focus from data collection and privacy to the inherently problematic power dynamic. It prioritises user autonomy over corporate interests, transforming social media business models to ensure that users become the customers of the firm, and not products for sale within the Empire for Rent.

Hannah McHugh is a postdoctoral fellow at Utrecht University working on Professor Ingrid Robeyns’ VICI funded project Visions of the Future. The project begins from calls for a new socio-economic model that could replace neo-liberal capitalism. The project seeks to analyse, compare and synthesise alternative proposals using a value-pluralist methodology. These proposals include accounts of degrowth, the well-being economy, the basic income society, workplace democracy, property-owning-democracy, stakeholder capitalism, community wealth building and others.

Hannah was previously a postdoctoral fellow of the Justitia Centre for Advanced Studies at Goethe University Frankfurt am Main. Hannah conducted her PhD in Political Theory at University College London and has taught at the London School of Economics.

Her main areas of interest are philosophical approaches to the contemporary market economy, neo-republican political theory, theories of political responsibility and social change, as well as feminist political thought.

Hannah is an elected Labour Party Councillor in Islington (London) and has a professional background in international financial services policy.