The Spectre of Hysteria and the Marginalisation of (Medically Unexplained) Multisystem Diseases
Long Covid Conversations organized by Eva Meijer | Speaker: Dr. Paula Muhr, University of Zurich and Technical University Berlin | Online | Registration: asca-fgw@uva.nl

Event details from: The Spectre of Hysteria and the Marginalisation of (Medically Unexplained) Multisystem Diseases
- Date
- 1 October 2024
- Time
- 12:00

Multisystem diseases, such as long COVID, myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS), Lyme disease, somatic symptom disorder (SSD) and functional neurological disorder (FND), are characterised by a multitude of heterogeneous symptoms for which the present-day medicine fails to provide either a clear-cut pathophysiological or an aetiological explanation. Moreover, these disorders are epidemiologically more prevalent in women, another aspect that currently lacks a medical explanation. Despite their differences, each of these diseases has been implicitly or explicitly associated with hysteria, an age-old illness whose medical legitimacy has been perennially contested during its several millennialong history. In the medical discourse, SSD and FND are seen as current medical labels for the symptoms that had historically been referred to as hysteria, a legacy that contributes to the continued marginalisation and stigmatisation of these present-day nosological categories. Conversely, the association between hysteria, on the one hand, and long COVID and ME/CFS, on the other hand, has not been proven but is nevertheless often suggestively implied both in the medical context and the general public as a way of delegitimising the medical validity of these diseases. Hysteria, thereby, is not understood as a historical label for a genuine though vaguely understood disease but as a catch-all phrase that jointly designates what is viewed as typically female emotional instability, pathological attention-seeking, abnormal illness behaviour, and simulation of illness for personal gains. In short, hysteria is used as a label for a psychosomatic/sociogenic construct that has no place in the domain of medicine. My talk aims to explore how current dismissals of long COVID, ME/CFS and FND as genuine medical conditions are underpinned by enduring historical stereotypes of hysteria as a predominantly female pseudo-illness that lacks a genuine physiological basis and is “all in your head.” It further aims to shed light on how the implicit blaming of patients for their medically unexplainable symptoms is grounded in the still-present mind-body dualism that informs the medical framing of these multisystem diseases.