Dissertation Defense Aartje van Dijk
Aartje van Dijk, ACLC PhD candidate, will defend her dissertation titled "Effects of instruction in writing-to-learn in different disciplines and types of education" on 1 February in the Agnietenkapel.
Event details from: Dissertation Defense Aartje van Dijk
- Date
- 1 February 2024
- Time
- 10:00 – 12:00
Effects of instruction in writing-to-learn in different disciplines and types of education
Students in all types of education often have difficulty acquiring topic knowledge and insight into subject matter of various disciplines. They do not understand or cannot remember theory from their textbook (Sampson & Phelps Walker, 2012; Hunter & Tse, 2013; Finkenstaedt-Quinn et al., 2017). Usually, students learn theory by studying textbooks, by listening closely to their teacher's explanations, or by discussing subject matter with peers. However, this is often not enough to get a grip on subject matter. Writing-to-learn can help; however, this way of learning is not yet much applied in education. In writing-to-learn, the aim is to promote learning by writing texts about subject matter. This allows students to reread their written knowledge and to reflect whether they have displayed the disciplinary content correctly. Writing-to-learn is writing with the aim to gain insight into subject matter and to acquire topic knowledge.
Writing-to-learn has been studied since the 1980s. At first, it was thought that writing brings about the learning process (strong text theory), but this appeared not always to be the case (Klein, 1999). A necessary condition to stimulate students' thinking is instruction of cognitive and metacognitive strategies in writing tasks, leading to new insights into and knowledge of subject matter (Bangert-Drowns et al., 2004). An example of instruction of a cognitive strategy in a writing task is: 'first try to organize the content of the text you are going to write in a meaningful way'. An example of instruction of a metacognitive strategy is: ‘write down which topics from the lesson you do not understand yet’ (Nückles et al., 2009). The instructions incite students to reflect. Reflection can support them to gain new insights into and topic knowledge of subject matter (Bereiter & Scardamalia, 1987).
The dissertation starts with a literature study by means of which was investigated which types of instruction in writing tasks have positive effects on learning in different types of education and disciplines. Subsequently, four quasi-experimental studies were carried out into the effects of a certain type of instruction in different types of education and disciplines. Following each of the four quasi-experiments, a think aloud study of the writing-to-learn process was conducted. A total of nine studies have been conducted.
Promotor:
- Prof. dr. Folkert Kuiken
Co-promotor:
- Dr. Amos van Gelderen