The Sting of Death: Why additive theories of well-being fail to meet the Epicurean challenge
Philosophy and Public Affairs | Prof. Govert den Hartogh (UvA) | Respondent: Dr. Gulzaar Barn (UvA)
Event details from: The Sting of Death: Why additive theories of well-being fail to meet the Epicurean challenge
- Date
- 19 April 2023
- Time
- 16:00 – 17:30

To the Epicurean contention that death cannot be bad for a person because non-existence is not a state of that person that can be compared to other states, the standard deprivation account replies that we can compare the shorter actual and the longer hypothetical life of that person. This only escapes the Epicurean challenge, I argue, if we recognise that the meaning and value of any part of a life may depend on the existence and character of other parts. This means that the deprivation account only succeeds if it is conjoined with a holistic rather than an additive theory of well-being.