Genre and the Historical Present: American Culture at the End of Growth
Guest Lecture by Sean O'Brien (University College Dublin) organized by Ben Moore | PCH 104
Event details from: Genre and the Historical Present: American Culture at the End of Growth
- Date
- 7 April 2022
- Time
- 17:00 – 18:30

At the January 2020 meeting of the American Economic Association, a “depressing consensus prevailed” amongst delegates: “the developed world is stuck with low growth…for years to come” (Greene 2020). Despite unprecedented stimulus packages, GDP growth across the advanced capitalist core had failed to recover from the Global Financial Crisis of 2008 even before the shock of the COVID-19 pandemic decimated the world market. This talk explores how post-2008 American literary texts and popular media trace the origins of this low-growth economy, or what macroeconomists call “secular stagnation,” to changes in real estate and energy policies in the late twentieth century. The theory of secular (or long-term) stagnation was originally proposed by the Keynesian economist Alvin E. Hansen during the Great Depression to account for persistent low growth and “weak and anaemic” (1939: 4) recoveries. Largely forgotten during the post-war boom, economists have recently revived this “macroeconomic heresy” (Backhouse and Boianovsky 2016) to explain the unusually sluggish performance of the global economy since the 2008 financial crisis.
The onset of secular stagnation brings into sharp relief the limits of capitalist expansion and growth – dynamics that underwrite not just capital accumulation but cultural representation, too, which has long been a site of identification and critical engagement with the developmental logics of capitalist modernity. How have writers and filmmakers sought to represent a moment in which stagnant economic growth threatens to erode the social forms that constitute our lifeworld? Approaching this question through the lens of genre, this talk examines historicist and investigative modes of narration in Thomas Pynchon’s detective novel, Inherent Vice (2009), and J.C. Chandor’s crime drama film, A Most Violent Year (2015). These contemporary neo-noir narratives use the conventions of crime fiction to uncover the origins of US decline. Where Pynchon mourns the golden years of American capitalism that died with the 60s counterculture, giving way to the boom-and-bust cycle of speculative development projects, Chandor links the petroleum-fueled rise of the FIRE sector at the outset of the Reagan era to the decline of the organized labour movement in the US. Bookending the transitional years of the 1970s, these narratives work as periodizing models that frame the 2008 subprime mortgage crisis and the current “energy impasse” (Szeman 2019) as products of what Robert Brenner (2006) has described as the late-twentieth-century transition from long boom to long downturn.
Sean O’Brien is a Government of Ireland Postdoctoral Fellow in the School of English, Drama and Film at University College Dublin. He was previously Lecturer in Modern and Contemporary Literature at Birkbeck, University of London. His research has been published in Cultural Critique, Discourse, Science Fiction Studies, Crossings and Bloomsbury’s Companion to Marx. He is co-editor of ‘Demos: We Have Never Been Democratic’, a special issue of the visual culture journal Public. His criticism has also appeared in GUTS Magazine, The Capilano Review, Vector and The Los Angeles Review of Books. Current research projects include a monograph, Representing Precarity: American Literature and Culture from Boom to Crisis, a collaborative book, Anti-Social Reproduction, and a postdoctoral research project, “World-System Failure: Secular Stagnation and Post-2008 American Culture.”