Higher Pain
You are kindly invited to join us for the next session of the Philosophy and Public Affairs Colloquium, which takes place April 23, 2025. We are looking forward to discussing a paper by Thomas Nys on J.S. Mill and to first comments by Eva Groen-Reijman.

Event details from: Higher Pain
- Date
- 23 April 2025
- Time
- 16:00 – 17:30
- Room
- OTM Faculty Room

You are kindly invited to join us for the next session of the PPA Colloquium, which takes place April 23, 2025. We are looking forward to discussing a paper by Thomas Nys on J.S. Mill and to first comments by Eva Groen-Reijman.
We will meet in the OTM Faculteitskamer II between 16:00 and 17:30. You are also welcome to join us on Zoom:
https://uva-live.zoom.us/j/9545368023. There will be drinks in de Jaren afterwards!
Abstract
Although Mill’s distinction between higher and lower pleasures is very well-known and continues to be a source of lively debate, almost no attention has been devoted to the idea of higher and lower pains. Since Mill’s utilitarian project aims both to prevent pain and promote happiness, the potential extension of the concepts of ‘higher’ and ‘lower’ to pain deserves careful consideration. In this contribution, I want to explore how we should understand these notions. I will start by giving a brief reconstruction of Mill’s distinction between higher and lower pleasures in Utilitarianism. Then, I will use that reconstruction to dispel some misgivings about the notion of higher pleasures. More precisely, I will argue that the focus on aesthetic pleasures, like those involved in reading books and attending operas, while not necessarily incorrect, is nevertheless unfortunate as it not only disregards the structure of the argument in Utilitarianism but also distracts from the fact that Mill is primarily concerned about incorporating virtuousness within the utilitarian framework. In a subsequent section, I will extend Mill’s analysis of pleasure to pains, by drawing a plausible parallel on the basis of Henry West’s Attitude Account. Finally, I will contend that my reconstruction of ‘higher pains’ aligns well with Mill’s treatment of the ‘positive evils of this world.’