Event details from: Epistemic injustice by AI – how profit prejudice imposes novel forms of epistemic injustice upon the digital democratic community

Date
19 March 2025
Time
16:00

You are also welcome to join us on Zoom: https://uva-live.zoom.us/j/9545368023

There will be drinks in De Jaren afterwards for which all are invited. If you want to join for the session aplease contact Yolande Jansen: <y.jansen@uva.nl>

Abstract:

Deliberative activities are susceptible to epistemic injustice. Digital deliberative activities form no exception. Despite the promise of formal inclusion, the distribution of participants’ contributions on social media platforms is subject to prejudice, which produces novel forms of epistemic injustice. This prejudice is imposed upon users by AI and is driven by business models that demand profit, which is ultimately established through the maximalisation of user engagement. In this paper I argue that the source of novel forms of epistemic injustice in digital deliberative spaces hides in what I call profit prejudice. I will show that profit prejudice imposes both structural testimonial and structural hermeneutical injustices upon users which undermines their opportunity to participate as equals in deliberative processes. This is problematic because the consequences of profit prejudice not only harm individuals as members of the democratic community but also harm the democratic community as a whole