Event details from: Sharing Use and Authority: The Value of Group Ownership

Date
11 October 2023
Time
16:00 – 17:30

11 October: Faculteitskamer OTM, 16:00 - 17:30

Speaker: Dr. Yara Al Salman (UU)

Commentator: Dr. Johan Olsthoorn (UvA)

Dr. Yara Al Salman is Assistant Professor of Ethics and Political Philosophy at Utrecht University, where she was previously awarded her doctorate (cum laude) after defending her dissertation on the nature of group ownership, within the NWO funded project ‘Private Property and Political Power in a Liberal Democratic Society’.

Sharing Use and Authority: The Value of Group Ownership

What is private group ownership and what, if anything, makes it a valuable institution? These questions are rarely addressed in philosophical property theories, which are concerned almost exclusively with individual ownership. To address this gap, I develop a conception of group ownership, explain what makes it valuable, and argue that under certain conditions it can be preferable to individual and public ownership.

Group ownership is the exclusive position of authority that is held by a group to decide how an object may be used, within limits set by law. In the conception I defend, this group is private and democratically organised. Focusing on the ownership of natural resources, I defend this institution in three steps. First, I demonstrate that shared resources do not succumb to a tragedy of the commons, as is often believed, but that group ownership enable people to share resources in a durable way in the face of adverse incentives. Second, I argue that sharing the use of a resource can help people to maximise its benefits. Finally, I argue that when multiple people use a resource, there are good reasons to give them an equal voice in its governance.